Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams

  • Mood:

Sometimes You Know Better Than to Keep Reading

One of those occasions is when you pick up a "classic" by WVO Quine, and read the introduction:

Logic, like any other science, has as its business the pursuit of truth.  What are true are certain statements and the pursuit of truth is the endeavor to sort out the true statements from the others, which are false.

Uh, no.  Logic is there to check consistency between statements, which is only one aspect of the truth of a statement.  Statements, in turn, are representations of situations, and both their adequacy and validity can be assessed separately.  Further, anyone who uses the word "business" like that in the first sentence must be alerted to the existence, and slipperiness, of metaphors, which dominate communication, and are the key to understanding what "statements" can mean.

And if he begins so badly, can he rescue himself later?

Frankly, I can't be bothered.

  • Working Class, Despised Class: A Study in Synonymy

    I return to an issue which some people have taken issue with me about. That is the issue of class. I continue to believe that a well-dressed white…

  • Secession

    Some people seem not to have noticed that the civil war was fought over "union" and whether citizens were citizens of the federal government as well…

  • British Government Seeking Your DNA

    For its public database, the British government wants the DNA of everybody -- including tourists. Think of it as a new spot on the entrance form.…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded