Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams

Are You Good at Math?

Usually a misleading question.

But then we came to a question: Why is it, if you want to go into programming, pedestrian ( or parental ) wisdom holds: “Are you good at math.”

This, parents, friends, teachers, I want to warn you away from asking. The question is not “are you good at math” but do you like symbolic systems, creating them, imagining them, adhering and bending them? That’s the question.

Good programmers are kids who memorize the armor charts to Dungeons and Dragons. Good programmers like to corollate data on baseball cards, they like to organize baseball cards. I’ve seen kids read chess books, or play Magic or play Yu-Gi-Oh, know the Dewy Decimal system, it’s all the same thing: breathing life into internal rules processing machines in your brain, and then using physical ( versus digital ) objects as the inputs to your automata.

So why do kids get asked “but are you good at math”.

Math is a convenient, albeit misleading, question, it’s a forced symbolic system that kids are forced to learn. To this extent, it can be used as a good measure of “will you be a good programmer”. Further, and a child has no way of knowing this, this lazy question implies that “liking math” and “liking the pedagogical approach used by the school board and as practiced by your teacher” are the same. They are wholly different and a child has no way of knowing this.

Read the whole thing.
Tags: education

  • Why aren't ethicists better people?

    Because there aren't a lot of better people around, but there are a lot of ethicists. This article points out that surveys indicate that ethicists…

  • Medical Ethics, and other contradictions

    The New York Times has an article on advance directives that highlights the "starve me even if I want to be fed" aspect of current law. It is…

  • Private law: Privilege

    Private law has a bad name, because it typically doesn't allow for a judge to look it over and see that people's rights were respected. Sometimes,…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded