Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams
notebuyer

Does Newspaper Coverage Encourage Our Enemies?

As it turns out, yes.

That doesn't argue well for the current crop of newspaper editors' discretion. But then, as I have pointed out before, they have no "news sense" anyway, so no discretion about what they discover to protect the boys from the community over there fighting is part and parcel of the same thing.

What's more discouraging is that, to most of them I've talked to, the boys aren't part of "their" community: there's a sub rosa identification with the cosmopolitan elite, rather than their inconveniently present neighbors. Maybe I just attract the wrong kind of editors/reporters.

Tyler Cowen, of Marginal Revolution, has some questions:

First, I fear that the measurement of satellite TV access of different Iraqi districts is a proxy for some other measure of district quality and that the TV programs have no causal role in driving killings. Is news access across Iraq really so different? Can't one district simply send an email to another district: "now is time to kill some more of them?" Second, I worry that the authors decided not to include Baghdad in the results.

The first objection is that news does not cause insurgency, it's merely correlated with it. The second part of that first objection explains why Baghdad wasn't included in the results: the gossip chain in large cities largely removes the ability to differentiate between newsfeeds that might have US input and ones that that don't.

I completely agree with his concluding comment: Still, if you want a jolt to your system, right now this paper is the place to go.
Tags: culture, war on terror
Subscribe

  • Governmental Laziness Has No Limits

    And, usually, their laziness means that you have to give up things so that they don't have to go through procedures that work, but take time.…

  • Learning From Bad Examples

    The lecture last night from CHAZ in Seattle: "We are not here to protest peacefully. We are here to disrupt! Does anybody know what happened to the…

  • Morgan K. Freeberg's Excellent Insight

    So I'm making a list of things that mean something other than what they're supposed to mean, and in a jolt I suddenly gain yet another new insight…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment