Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams

  • Mood:

Science: Foreign to Environmentalists

Here's a brief review of a longer essay on a topic of wide interest: Why are environmentalists so clueless about the environment? Haven't they taken biology in school?

Oddly enough, the answer is usually "No." They didn't take it once they learned that they would have to dissect frogs. I had to dissect a cat in Physiology at my high school, and I understand that not everyone wants to be exposed to formaldehyde. I didn't like it all that well myself. But the knowledge from that course has come in handy in many ways.

Ecology is a science. Thre are things that you learn from studying it which can be experimentally validated. It requires physics, chemistry, zoology, and accurate observation, combined with statistical fluency, to come up with worthwhile results. That requirement is foreign to environmentalists, who generaly identify pollution with "something artificial" and "man-made". When you ask them to talk further about it, and whether sewage is pollution, they answer, "Yes, of course." It hasn't occured to them to look at other animals' contribution to public health, and they have confused their subjects. Yes, public health requires attention to water sources and problems. No, sewage is not a pollutant: it is a public health hazard. To solve this, we require "artificial" and "man-made" responses: pipes, ponds, burns, filters, and toilets are on the list: which should be cheered, not criticized.

Eventually, they will have to notice that human beings are part of nature, too. Our part includes stewardship, which leads to worthwhile discussions about use and advantage. It does not include saying, "Let's get rid of the people, that will solve our problem."

  • Why Science Discourages Kids

    Because they pay attention to Carl Sagan, and others like him. If all you see is that anything you do doesn’t matter, there goes any reason to do…

  • Another Reason to Distrusts Ethicists or Accusations of Bad Ethics

    This time, a study from the Wharton School which points out that people who accuse others of being unethical get points from people who see them do…

  • Blind Auditions

    In symphony orchestras, auditions are conducted behind a sheet, so that the listeners react only to the virtuosity of the player, not their gender or…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded