Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams
notebuyer

Tenure, and Two Kinds of Academic Research

From the invaluable Megan McArdle:

Is this[publication mania] producing better education? Doubtful; there's no particular relationship between scholarship and the ability to teach. How about valuable scholarship? Well, define valuable--in many liberal arts fields, the only possible consumer of the research in question is a handful of scholars in the same field. That sort of research is valuable in the same way that children's craft projects are priceless--to their mothers. Basically, these people are supporting an expensive hobby with a sideline business certifying the ability of certain twenty-year olds to write in complete sentences.


And because it is valuable mostly to their mothers or as a line on an unfollowedup resume, disappearing into the stacks of the few universities which subscribe to the publications in which the articles appear, that fraud periodically raises its head on tenure track.
Subscribe

  • Summing up....

    "Patriot Post US" occasionally has the most fun with news...

  • The Constitution and "Reasonableness"

    Reid et al. are looking into regulating burning Korans. Because some obscure guy burned one and some loony people (Muslims, not condemned by other…

  • Airlines: It was a nice trip.

    Inspired by this piece, and the letter from UCSF about problems with radiation in TSA applications and the incapacity of TSA to distinguish what…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments