Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams

Revolutions - and Pushback

Sweeping things to one side or the other rarely produces total victory. I note that for a long time, the electorate is roughly 50-50 Democrat and Republican, and the Era of Trump has probably not changed that significantly, though the riots and the MSM may have led to a pushback by those aware that extremes are dangerous, whether Communist, Nazi, or corruptocrat.

Victor Davis Hanson, previously cited in these pages, has some comments about how revolutionary parties die out, or don't, with caveats. I'd take the Napoleon-Stalin model more seriously if I were him: both of them came out of "nowhere" (Corsica and Georgia, respectively), and took over a group of disaffected people. Read the article. Comment as you see fit.

Update I'd take the Napoleon-Stalin model even more seriously once you notice that while Trump is restrained by the Constitution, his opponents are not. The courts around the United States are no longer interested in interpreting the law: they want to approve whatever high-handed measures the Left is taking in their state. Oppression is cool for Leftists, while they accuse the Right of plotting it, and say how awful the Right is to do so, they actually do it and approve of it. As noted here, the Left deliberately inverts the idea of "responsibility" and "punishment" to encourage those out of control to destroy things. It recalls this “Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves.” – William Pitt's remark should be the reminder that we are individuals, and do things differently because of it, not seeking the uniformity of necessity.

Retraction Don Surber points out that some courts restrain the government over-reach and uses Michigan as his example. I am duly abashed, and exempt Michigan from my critique. For the moment.
Tags: civil war, revolution, sjw, vdh

  • Why aren't ethicists better people?

    Because there aren't a lot of better people around, but there are a lot of ethicists. This article points out that surveys indicate that ethicists…

  • Medical Ethics, and other contradictions

    The New York Times has an article on advance directives that highlights the "starve me even if I want to be fed" aspect of current law. It is…

  • Private law: Privilege

    Private law has a bad name, because it typically doesn't allow for a judge to look it over and see that people's rights were respected. Sometimes,…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded