Arnold Williams (notebuyer) wrote,
Arnold Williams
notebuyer

Thoughts in Response

A quote found in Jeff's Blog

"The ethics of journalism begin with propositions like: the world is basically intelligible if we have accurate reports about it; public opinion exists and ought to be listened to; through the observation of events we can grasp patterns and causes underneath them; the circle of people who know how things work should be enlarged; there is something called “the public record” and news adds itself meaningfully to it; more information is good for it leads to greater awareness, which is also good; stories about strangers have morals and we need to hear them, and so on. These are the ethics I would teach first….
"Alas, I used to teach that the world needs more critics; but it was an unexamined thing. Today I would say that the world has a limited tolerance for critics, and while it always needs more do-ers, it does not always need more chroniclers, pundits, or pencil-heads."


One of the interesting points here is that the speaker wants to cut off criticism and punditry, presumably because some of it is aimed at positions he holds dear. I'd say the world always needs more chroniclers, and better ones at that: and punditry can come in and help develop the meaning and application of those chronicles.

What do you think?
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments